Bluefire Insurance

After a stunning Q1 with record-breaking premium and loss ratios, the U.S. private auto insurance market heads into murky waters in the latter half of 2023. 

According to an S&P Global Market Intelligence report covering auto insurance industry trends, premiums skyrocketed in Q1 from $68.84 billion to $76.30 billion, an increase of $7.48 billion or nearly 11%. This double-digit growth was driven by the following factors: 

• Increased loss rates as drivers spend more time on the road as companies roll out RTO policies 
• Inflation and elevated vehicle market prices from continued supply chain issues 
• Higher repair costs from labor and parts shortages 

You can expect to see agents facing similar patterns throughout the end of 2023. This guide will help you navigate these challenging auto insurance industry trends with your clients. 

1. Auto Loss Rates Will Continue Rising Due to Return to Office (RTO) 

More and more companies are requiring their employees to return to the office, a trend that will likely continue well into next year. Since most workers in the United States commute to their employers by car outside of major metropolitan areas like New York City and Chicago, accident rates will continue to rise, leading to greater losses. 

With higher loss rates come higher premiums, a point to emphasize to your clients when they inevitably ask about higher prices. This type of transparency can go a long way toward making your client relationships stronger in uncertain economic times. 

2. Clients Will Become More Price Sensitive from Inflation and Economic Slowdowns 

Everything has become more expensive, and the 2023 auto insurance market is no exception. While it usually targets an average 2% inflation rate, the Federal Reserve’s consumer prices inflation time series chart shows that inflation skyrocketed post-pandemic to levels not seen since the 1970s. 

While inflation has slightly cooled in 2023, it remains elevated year-over-year. Your clients will continue to become more price-sensitive as daily necessities become more expensive, necessitating adding additional value to the sales process. 

In October, younger generations like Gen Z and Millennials will face additional economic pressure from the looming student loan repayment resumptions. Young drivers will become especially frugal as they shop for the lowest premiums regardless of brand loyalty. 

3. Used Car Supply Will Remain Tight Due to Ongoing Labor Shortages 

The Federal Reserve also maintains a chart detailing the consumer price index (CPI) for used cars and trucks. This metric almost doubled as the pandemic kicked off, in large part due to choked supply chains and stay-at-home orders issued by governments. 

With car prices remaining elevated, insurers will need to raise premiums to compensate for the additional value-at-risk associated with these temporarily high vehicle prices. 

Nevertheless, the used car market will likely remain hot through the end of the year and potentially beyond — into 2024 — due to additional trade conflicts with China. 

4. Repair Costs Will Continue Climbing — and Take Longer to Complete 

Several factors are driving the price increases in the repair industry, including difficult-to-fix supply chain bottlenecks, labor shortages, and collapsing trade relations between the U.S. and other major economic powers like China. 

You can use this talking point when speaking with clients to emphasize how the broader economy impacts their premiums. By coupling this discussion with incentives around discounts and other ways to save, you can help mitigate the challenges posed by rising insurance prices. 

5. Clients Will Become Unhappier with the Claims Process 

According to the J.D. Power 2022 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, clients became significantly less satisfied with the claims process year-over-year. This drop appears to be mostly driven by increased repair times and a lack of communication from auto insurers. 

To help mitigate this potential risk, stay in touch with clients and provide transparent timing information. 

Navigate Challenging Auto Insurance Industry Trends with a Trusted Partner 

The most crucial aspect that makes independent agencies like yours successful is the right partnership and access to auto insurance emerging technology. Bluefire Insurance helps small agencies grow and succeed with innovative auto insurance solutions backed by top-rated insurers. To learn more, call 866-424-9511 or submit a request for more information online.